We know more than ever about concussions, the permanent brain damage of chronic traumatic encephalopathy and the other physical risks of football.
Yet so far this year, at least 19 students have died playing football, according to the University of North Carolina's National Center for Catastrophic Sport Injury Research.
Though participation is slowly declining, football is still the country's most popular high school sport. Over a million high schoolers played last season.
Researchers at UNC have been tracking football-related deaths since the 1960s. Director Kristen Kucera describes two main tallies: deaths caused directly by football, like a broken spine or brain trauma, and those that are indirect like heat stroke or sudden cardiac arrest that occurred during a game or practice.
The good news is that there are fewer fatalities than there used to be. Back in the 1960s, around 30 or 40 players died each year. Then came a steep decline thanks to new safety measures: a standardized helmet that must be certified for use in a game; a rule banning headfirst tackling; and improvements in athletic medical care.
But instead of dropping to nil, the number of football-related fatalities leveled off in the 1990s. Since then, a persistent average of about four or five football players have died each year as a direct result of playing their sport, along with an average of 10 or so indirect fatalities.
When asked why the numbers have leveled off instead of reaching zero, Kucera hesitates. "That's a great question," she says. "That's what we're working really hard to figure out."
One player who died this year was Cam'ron Matthews, a 16-year-old from Alto, Texas.
On a Friday night in November, one month after Matthews died, the Alto Yellowjackets bounded out of their black-and-yellow inflated tent through an artificial cloud of mist and onto the field. There was no trace of sadness. They were focused on winning.
Alto is a small town of about 1,200, and on Friday nights it feels like everyone comes to watch the boys play. Some parents like Misty Collins get there early to stake out a spot on the metal bleachers. Collins was there Oct. 16, when Matthews told the coach he felt dizzy, then collapsed on the sideline.
"We just all prayed," she remembered. "We prayed that he was going to be OK, but the good Lord took an angel that was down here on Earth."
That's how people who knew Matthews talk about him. The 6-foot safety was one of the team's captains. He was the only junior elected.
"He's our number one, that was his jersey number," Collins said. "He was an awesome student, and very polite, and anything that came out of his mouth was 'Yes, ma'am' and 'No, ma'am.' He was an awesome guy."
After he collapsed, medics took Matthews to a hospital in East Texas, where he died the next day.
Doctors told the family he likely died from a burst brain aneurysm, though they're still waiting for an autopsy to confirm that.
A fatal aneurysm could be related to football or other vigorous activity, according to Robert Cantu, a neurosurgeon in Concord, Mass., who specializes in football injuries. That activity could cause an aneurysm, which is a weak area in the wall of an artery, to burst, which in turn could cause dizziness, collapse and death. Aneurysms can run in families, but are "very uncommon" in 16-year-olds, Cantu says.
Matthews' friend and teammate Keenan Johnson said it's been hard to get back in the groove. But instead of falling apart, he says, the team has pulled together.
"It hurts that he's not here," Johnson says. "He's one of my closest friends, and we worked out all summer. But we dedicate it to him. We're trying to win the state championship for him, be number one for him."
In the playoff game in November, the Yellowjackets faced a longtime rival – the Groveton Indians. And Matthews was on the sidelines, in a way. His number 1 jersey was perched on a wooden hanger. His sister Paige sat in the bleachers at the 50-yard line. The team won 63 to 14.
Parents rushed onto the field to thank head coach Paul Gould. Gould says he's proud of how the players are handling their teammate's death.
"I think they're doing probably about as good as possible, but this is something they're going to deal with for the rest of their lives," he says.
Gould knows parents are concerned about injuries associated with football, especially concussions. This year the governing body for high school sports in Texas says it will start counting concussions for the first time.
This month, the American Academy of Pediatrics made new recommendations about safety and urged players to consider "whether the benefits of playing outweigh the risks of possible injury." The AAP is urging the expansion of non-tackle leagues like flag football and calling for athletic trainers to be present during practices and games. Only 37 percent of high school nationwide have a full time athletic trainer on staff.
Two University of Minnesota professors have gone even further, calling for the elimination of tackle football programs from public schools altogether.
"Everybody wants their kids to be safe. Everybody wants their kids to be OK, and I understand that," Gould says. "We try to make sure we coach kids to hit the correct way. You try to make your kids as safe as possible, because that's our job."
After Matthews died, Gould says not a single parent pulled their kid from the team. He hopes what happened doesn't fuel negative ideas about the game.
"I can say this: What football teaches kids for the rest of their life, in my opinion, is priceless," Gould says. "I mean, it teaches you to deal with things. This situation is definitely teaching our kids to deal with things as they move forward."
But players who have been involved in a fatal play say the experience will haunt them forever.
Back in 1989, Brad Gaines was a star running back at Vanderbilt University. Then came October 28, a date Gaines will never forget. It was a must-win game at Ole Miss in Oxford.
Vanderbilt received the opening kickoff and drove down the field. On third and goal at the 12-yard line, Gaines and the Commodores lined up for a play designed to pass the ball to Gaines.
The ball snapped and his quarterback threw the pass. An Ole Miss linebacker was close on Gaines's tail.
"As soon as the ball reaches me, reaches my hands ... bang!" Gaines remembers. "Just a fantastic hit from the back, and breaks up the pass, and [the linebacker] just makes a great play."
Gaines headed back to the sideline, then noticed the linebacker hadn't yet gotten back up. At first, Gaines thought this was another of football's routine injuries. A sprained ankle, maybe. But five minutes went by. Ten minutes. The linebacker was still lying on the field, surrounded by trainers and medical staff. Maybe a broken arm, Gaines thought.
Finally Gaines realized it was something more serious when a helicopter ambulance arrived to take the linebacker to Memphis, about 70 miles away.
Later he learned the linebacker's name — Chucky Mullins — and his injury: Mullins had broken his spine and could not move any of his limbs.
"I had the doctor tell me sometime later that when they got him stabilized, when they got him into surgery... his neck looked as if you dropped a grenade down his shirt."
Gaines was horrified.
"The only thing I knew was you strapped up your cleats before practice, you went out and played and it was fun. I didn't know that there was this other part to this game," says Gaines, now 48 and living in Nashville, where he works in health care.
"In an instant, he goes from being a world-class athlete in the best conference in America, and now he's laying on his back, and he'll never move again. He will not be able to brush his teeth. He will not be able to wash his hair. He will never be able to feed himself. And I just felt like I was the cause of that."
Against the advice of his coach and a psychologist, Gaines decided to visit Mullins in the hospital. He was scared to death, petrified, he says, and not prepared for what he saw when he walked in: a much skinnier Mullins, with "cords, tubes, things hanging out of him."
Mullins's guardian was there, and told Gaines that Mullins had something he wanted to tell him.
Gaines leaned over to hear Mullins whisper through his tracheal tube: "It's not your fault."
"And oh my goodness," Gaines remembers. "It's tough saying it now, but I tell you, it was a total selfless act on his part. I don't know if I could have done that."
Gaines and Mullins remained friends for the following year and half, until Mullins died of complications in 1991. Every year still, he drives to Mullins's grave on October 28, the anniversary of the game, and on Christmas.
Today, Gaines regularly receives phone calls from players like him — players, often teenagers, who make a routine play or tackle that ends with an opponent's death. Gaines is one of few people they can turn to who actually understands what they're going through, and he's happy to help.
"What I learned from Chucky Mullins was that selfless nature. It's not about me. It's not about Brad Gaines. I can help people. So if somebody calls me and asks me that's going through something like this, or needs some advice, or counsel, then that's my duty."
Gaines thinks the game is safer today, thanks to things like better concussion protocol and the new kickoff positions that mean fewer kickoff returns. But he still calls himself a football purist. He says he couldn't tell his 11-year-old son not to play football.
"I know that it's not the game's fault. I know that. And I know that there are going to be injuries," Gaines says. "But when you love the game, you accept that. You accept that there could be consequences like this."
Lauren Silverman reports for NPR member station KERA in Dallas.
ARI SHAPIRO, HOST:
So far this year, at least 19 people have died directly or indirectly from playing football. Most of them are high school kids. This is according to the National Center for Catastrophic Sport Injury Research, and the center says that number is higher than the recent average.
KELLY MCEVERS, HOST:
Now we're going to take a look at how these football deaths affect the communities where they happen and the players. Earlier this season, Cam'ron Williams (ph), a high school junior from Alto, Texas, died after collapsing on the sidelines. Lauren Silverman of member station KERA went to an Alto High game and sent this report.
LAUREN SILVERMAN, BYLINE: On a Friday night one month after Cam'ron Matthews died, the Alto Yellowjackets bounded out of their black and yellow inflated tent through an artificial cloud of mist onto the field. On Friday nights, it feels like just about everyone from the small town of Alto comes out to watch the boys play. Some parents, like Misty Collins, get there early to stake out a spot on the metal bleachers. Collins was there last month when 16-year-old Cam'ron Matthews told the coach he felt dizzy then collapsed on the sideline.
MISTY COLLINS: We just all prayed. We prayed that, you know, he was going to be OK, but the good Lord took an angel.
SILVERMAN: An angel - that's how people talk about Matthews. The 6-foot safety was one of the team's captains - the only junior elected.
COLLINS: He was an awesome student and very polite, and anything that come out of his mouth was, yes, Ma'am, no Ma'am. And he's just an awesome - he was an awesome guy.
SILVERMAN: After he collapsed, medics took Matthews to a hospital in East Texas. Doctors told the family he likely died from a brain aneurysm, but they're still waiting for autopsy results. In the meantime, we asked a neurosurgeon what he thought. He said physical activity like playing football or another sport could cause a brain aneurysm to burst. Kids with a family history of aneurysms are more risk.
Matthew's friend and teammate Keenan Johnson said it's been hard to get back in the groove. But instead of fall apart, the team's actually pulled together.
KEENAN JOHNSON: It hurts that he's not here. You know, he's one of my closest friends, and we worked out all summer. But you know, we dedicated to him. We trying to win the state championchip for him, be No. 1 for him.
SILVERMAN: In the opening round of the playoffs, the Yellowjackets faced a longtime rival, Groveton Indians, and Matthews was on the sideline in a way. His number one jersey was perched on a wooden hanger for folks in the stands to see. His sister Paige sat in the bleachers at the 50-yard line.
SILVERMAN: The Yellowjackets won 63 to 14. Parents rushed onto the field to thank head coach Paul Gould. Gould said he's proud of how the players are handling their teammate's death.
PAUL GOULD: I think they're doing probably about as good as possible. But this is something they're going to deal with the rest of their lives, you know?
SILVERMAN: Gould knows some parents are concerned about injuries associated with football, especially concussions. This year, the governing body for high school sports in Texas says it will start counting concussions for the first time. After Matthews died, Gould said not a single parent pulled their kid from the team. He hopes what happened doesn't fuel negative ideas about the game.
GOULD: I can say this. What football teaches kids for the rest of their life, in my opinion, is priceless. I mean, it teaches you to deal with things. This situation is definitely teaching our kids to deal with things as they move forward.
MCEVERS: That was Lauren Silverman reporting from Texas. A lot of these football deaths happen after a tackle on the field. One player dies; another survives. Brad Gaines is one of those survivors. He played football in high school and college. Two of his brothers played in the NFL.
BRAD GAINES: What our family was built around was athletics. You went from football to basketball to baseball and then back to football, to basketball, to based. And it never stopped.
MCEVERS: In 1989, Gaines was in his junior year at Vanderbilt - a fullback. And on October 28, they were playing Ole Miss. Vanderbilt is near the end zone. The quarterback sends a short pass to Gaines.
GAINES: As soon as the ball reaches my hands...
MCEVERS: He gets tackled.
GAINES: Bang - just a fantastic hit from the back and breaks up the pass, and he just makes a great play.
MCEVERS: But the player who tackled Brad Gaines did not get back up off the ground.
GAINES: Five minutes went by, and then 10 minutes went by. And you still don't think anything major.
MCEVERS: And at that moment, you didn't know his name.
GAINES: No, no, no, no.
MCEVERS: But had later learned that his name was...
GAINES: Chucky Mullins.
MCEVERS: Chucky Mullins was airlifted to a hospital in Memphis. He was paralyzed.
GAINES: You know, I had the doctor tell me sometime later that his neck looked as if you dropped a grenade down his shirt. It was not good.
MCEVERS: And you later visited him in the hospital.
GAINES: I did. And so Kelly, I struggled with this 'cause I had never been through this.
GAINES: I mean, the only thing I knew was you, you know, you strapped up your cleats before practice. You went out and played, and it was fun. I didn't know that there was this other part to this game. In an instant, he goes from being a world-class athlete in the best conference in America. And now he's lying on his back, and he'll never move again. I just felt like I was the cause of that.
And so I told myself, I've got to go meet him. And I drive my old beat-up car down there. I went in, Kelly, and I was not prepared for what I was seeing, you know? His body has physically deteriorated. He has cords, tubes. And so he - you know, he has this trachea in his mouth, and he can't speak. And you know, he can puff and - so you know, you got to lean your ear down to his mouth, to that trachea area. And when I leaned down, Kelly, he said, it's not your fault. And oh, my goodness - I mean, it's tough saying it now. I tell you, it was a total selfless act on his part. I don't know if I could've done that.
MCEVERS: Brad Gaines kept visiting Chucky Mullins. They became friends. Then a year-and-a-half after the tackle, Chucky Mullins died of complications from the injury. Brad Gaines quit football for a while then played again. And now when someone dies playing football, he gets calls from the players who survived. He talks to them about the guilt but says he doesn't blame football.
GAINES: I know that it's not the game's fault. I know that. And I know that there are going to be injuries in plays like that. There will be kids that will lose their life on that field every year. I mean, that's just part of the game. But when you love the game, you accept that. You accept that there could be consequences like this.
MCEVERS: You have kids, right?
GAINES: I do. I have three girls, but I do have a son, yes.
MCEVERS: Does he play football?
GAINES: He does. And the - I think the normal instinct would be to not let him play. But I can't do that. I can't - that would not be fair to him if I said, you're not going to play football because you're going to get hurt or of some of the things that I've went through.
MCEVERS: Have you told your son about Chucky Mullins?
GAINES: He does know about Chucky.
MCEVERS: And I understand your son chose to wear a specific number.
GAINES: He did. Chucky was number 38. He said, Dad, you know, I want to wear a 38. And it made my heart feel really good.
MCEVERS: That's Brad Gaines, a former football player for Vanderbilt University. He says he still visits Chucky Mullins's grave every year. Transcript provided by NPR, Copyright NPR.