© 2024 Kansas City Public Radio
NPR in Kansas City
Play Live Radio
Next Up:
0:00 0:00
Available On Air Stations

Zuma Survives (Another) No-Confidence Vote In South Africa's Parliament

Supporters of the opposition Democratic Alliance march against President Jacob Zuma ahead of the motion of a no confidence vote against him in Cape Town, South Africa.
Brenton Geach
Getty Images
Supporters of the opposition Democratic Alliance march against President Jacob Zuma ahead of the motion of a no confidence vote against him in Cape Town, South Africa.

Updated at 12:44 p.m. ET

South African President Jacob Zuma survived the sixth push for a vote of no confidence Tuesday — and for the first time, the vote was held by secret ballot. The embattled Zuma's African National Congress party, which controls Parliament, overcame speculation that a secret vote might prove to be his undoing.

The final vote was 198 to 177, with nine abstentions. The motion of no confidence would have needed 201 votes to remove Zuma from office.

Debate over the measure began at 2 p.m. local time (8 a.m. ET) Tuesday, in a session that was also streamed online. Outside Parliament, protesters gathered to await word of the results.

After roughly two hours of spirited debate, National Assembly Speaker Baleka Mbete asked for a voice vote. After a chorus of shouts responded to each call for votes in favor and against, she pronounced, "I think the 'no's' have it."

But at that point, a call came to hold the vote by secret ballot, as had been planned.

Business was then halted to allow the installation of four large white voting booths on the floor of the chamber, to allow members to cast their votes on the no-confidence motion.

Some 40 minutes later, Mbete ordered the doors to be locked so that the vote could proceed. Members then filed to the four booths as their names were called, to collect a ballot and choose from three options: either "no" or "yes" — or to abstain.

The vote was halted more than once, as members of Parliament objected to cameras in the gallery. In the end, staff were sent to escort media agencies' photographers from the gallery.

"Vote with your conscience and remove this corrupt and broken president from office," said Mmusi Maimane, who leads the opposition Democratic Alliance party, early in Tuesday's session.

In a speech that ended with applause and handshakes, Maimane added, "I plead you: Let us put the people of South Africa first and vote to remove Jacob Zuma today."

When it was his turn at the podium, Zuma's ANC ally Pule Mabe called today's vote "yet another frivolous and fruitless motion."

"Our movement, the ANC, has led the charge in liberating the people of South Africa and leading the rest of society to a right path," Mabe said. "This motion is nothing else but a test of character."

As Peter Granitz reports for NPR from Pretoria, the use of a secret ballot meant that "hesitant members of Zuma's African National Congress could break rank without fear repercussions from the party. Opposition parties [needed] to poach about 50 ANC members to vote with them and oust the president from office. That's a heavy lift."

In the end, the opposition got some 40 votes from ANC members.

The numerous attempts to dislodge Zuma from office have led to some confusion over how many no-confidence votes he has faced. According to the website Africa Check, three motions to remove Zuma have gone to a vote; the remaining two failed because they were either withdrawn or amended.

First elected in 2009, Zuma was re-elected in 2014. His current term is set to end in 2019.

Zuma has long been dogged by accusations of corruption. As Tuesday's vote arrived, South Africans are also suffering from a rocky economy: The country's credit rating was dropped to a junk rating this spring, and the unemployment rate is nearly 28 percent.

And this summer, leaked emails described how Zuma's son, Duduzane Zuma, had avoided charges over a fatal car crash in which his Porsche wrecked a taxi. Two women who had been in the taxi died after that crash.

Speaking in Parliament on Tuesday, the leader of the opposition Economic Freedom Fighters, Julius Malema — who, like his fellow members, was dressed in red — said his party's goal wasn't to remove a democratically elected leader.

"We are here to remove Duduzane's father, because Duduzane's father is the most corrupt individual in this country," he said.

The ANC's Nathi Mthethwa, the minister of arts and culture, said that his party would resolve its problems on its own, and he called on Parliament to resist what he called an attempt at a coup d'etat.

To those who had called for today's vote, he added, "the ANC will not be lectured by the upstarts, the startups, and some Mickey Mouse organizations like yourselves."

Copyright 2020 NPR. To see more, visit https://www.npr.org.

Bill Chappell is a writer and editor on the News Desk in the heart of NPR's newsroom in Washington, D.C.
KCUR serves the Kansas City region with breaking news and award-winning podcasts.
Your donation helps keep nonprofit journalism free and available for everyone.