NPR in Kansas City
Play Live Radio
Next Up:
Available On Air Stations
Up To Date

A Fan's Notes: Jinx


At least one local college football team is on the brink of a perfect season. But as Victor Wishna explains in this month's edition of "A Fan's Notes," that storybook ending is in jeopardy, thanks to a cover.

With two weeks left in the college football season, the Kansas State Wildcats are a perfect 10—as in, 10-0. And they’re currently number one in the BCS standings, for the first time in school history. Coach Bill Snyder, who came out of retirement three years ago to resurrect the football program for a second time, is on the verge of his and K-State’s first national championship.

But this week, something terrible has happened: the current issue of Sports Illustrated is out and there he is on the cover: the Wildcat’s star quarterback, Collin Klein. And it gets worse—the all-caps caption declares him “the best player on the nation’s best team.” Ouch.

Or, more specifically, Curses! Every sports fan is aware—or should be—of the infamous Sports Illustrated “cover jinx.” To be chosen as the illustrious magazine’s headliner is humbling and potentially harmful, a foreboding foreshadow of doom on the field—or, heaven forbid, off it.

It started with the very first issue of SI in 1954 and its first cover boy, Milwaukee Braves third baseman Eddie Mathews. The Braves soon snapped a nine-game winning streak and Mathews broke his hand. There have been dozens more ill-fated incidences since, a litany of not just batting slumps, losing streaks, and shocking upsets, but also season-ending injuries, fatal car crashes, and family tragedies.

The cover jinx has hit home before. In 2003, the Kansas City Chiefs appeared above the effusive headline “9-0!” A week later, their record was nine-and-one. Five years ago, the undefeated Kansas Jayhawks—yes, the football team—were featured for their own “Dream Season.” The Missouri Tigers would rudely awaken them a few days later.

Superstition is as much a part of sports as statistics. Some rituals are practically rules of the game, from rally caps to playoff beards. And for sports fans, whose affliction is pinning hope to something over which we already have no control, superstition can be the perfect salve. When things go wrong, belief in the supernatural brings order. There’s a very good reason why the Red Sox didn’t win a World Series for eighty-six years, why the Cubs are still flailing, or why no team from Cleveland or Buffalo can win anything: they’re hexed. Psychologists will tell you that it’s all, well, psychological. But as a Royals and Chiefs fan, I get it. Sitting around and cursing the bums in the front office ain’t got nothin’ on “The Curse of the Bambino.”

One of the allures of a jinx is in never knowing when it will strike. After all, Sports Illustrated has produced nearly 3,000 covers, most of them quite harmless to their subjects. Michael Jordan set the record, with 51 appearances, and he seemed to do okay.

When the Wildcats take on the Baylor Bears tomorrow night, they will still be the heavy favorite. The only cover of concern to Vegas bookmakers involves the twelve-point spread.

And an online poll of K-State fans so far finds that only 16 percent think their team is jinxed. Rational thought, or wishful thinking?

Reporters, of course, were clamoring to know how Klein himself felt about his complicated milestone. “Oh, it's pretty cool,” he said, sounding less than cursed. “At the same time, I am just trying to take care of…business here. Just trying to take one more step.”

Because that’s the comforting thing about a jinx. Real or imagined, there’s not much you can do about it.

Victor Wishna is a writer, editor, author, and sports fan.  He lives in Leawood.  You can hear “A Fan’s Notes” monthly on Up to Date.

Stephen Steigman is director of Classical KC and chief of broadcast operations for KCUR 89.3 and 91.9 Classical KC.
Victor Wishna is a contributing author and commentator for Up to Date.