© 2024 Kansas City Public Radio
NPR in Kansas City
Play Live Radio
Next Up:
0:00 0:00
Available On Air Stations

Independence Woman Says She’ll Continue Her Fight Against Second Man Accused Of Rape

Courtesy of Taylor Hirth
Taylor Hirth is a survivor of rape. Thursday, a Jackson County judge sentenced William Luth to 30 years in prison for the 2016 rape.

Taylor Hirth said she was in good spirits Thursday after a Jackson County judge sentenced her rapist to 30 years in prison.

William Luth, 26, of Blue Springs, Missouri, pleaded guilty Thursday for breaking into Hirth’s apartment in February 2016 and raping her in front of her then two-year-old daughter.

Hirth reported the incident, had a rape kit done and turned in DNA evidence to Independence police, but she has criticized how the department handled the case.

Luth is serving a 41-year prison sentence for raping a Johnson County sheriff's deputy later that year.

Credit Johnson County Sheriff's Office
William Luth, right, was sentenced to 30 years in prison Thursday for the 2016 rape of an Independence woman in her apartment. Brady Newman-Caddell, left, was also charged but has yet to be sentenced.

Brady Newman-Caddell, 23, of Independence, Missouri, has been charged in both cases.

Newman-Caddell was set to be sentenced Wednesday in Johnson County, but withdrew his guilty plea and requested a trial, prompting his defense attorney to drop the case.

Hirth was in the Johnson County court Wednesday along with the deputy and another woman who alleges she was abused by Newman-Caddell. She said they all were surprised by his change of plea.

“Once again we’re just kind of getting pulled along by the system. Everything is getting delayed, and we’re all waiting for closure,” she said.

Newman-Caddell will be assigned a new defense attorney before his next court appearance on Feb. 7.

Hirth said she has been vocal about her story, in part, because if someone had been victimized in the past and decided to get a rape kit, her own rape may never have happened.

“You start to realize just how damaging and impactful it is when somebody holds it to themselves and doesn’t come forward and try to seek their own justice,” she said. “It’s hard, and it’s long, and it’s painful, but it’s just going to keep happening again until people find it within themselves to fight back.”

Andrea Tudhope is a reporter for KCUR 89.3. Email her at andreat@kcur.org, and follow her on Twitter @andreatudhope.

Andrea Tudhope is an award-winning multimedia journalist based in Kansas City, Missouri. She is currently coordinating producer for America Amplified, a national public media community engagement initiative funded by the Corporation for Public Broadcasting. 
KCUR serves the Kansas City region with breaking news and award-winning podcasts.
Your donation helps keep nonprofit journalism free and available for everyone.