© 2025 Kansas City Public Radio
NPR in Kansas City
Play Live Radio
Next Up:
0:00
0:00
0:00 0:00
Available On Air Stations

Trump urges Missouri Republicans to redistrict Rep. Emanuel Cleaver out of his seat

Missouri Republicans may return to session this fall to target Democratic Congressman Emanuel Cleaver, seen here in a 2016 photo. Cleaver's Kansas City-based district is solidly Democratic, but it could be transformed into a Republican district.
U.S. Rep. Emanuel Cleaver greets two Bernie Sanders supporters in Philadelphia in 2016. Missouri Republicans may target Cleaver's 5th District seat later this fall.
Missouri Republicans may return to session this fall to target Democratic Congressman Emanuel Cleaver, seen here in a 2016 photo. Cleaver's Kansas City-based district is solidly Democratic, but it could be transformed into a Republican district.

If Missouri Republicans revamp their map to oust Kansas City Democrat Emanuel Cleaver, it could backfire at the ballot box — and in court. President Trump is publicly urging Republican-led states to pursue mid-decade redistricting to win more U.S. House seats.

President Donald Trump wants Missouri to join in on a mid-decade redistricting extravaganza ahead of the midterm elections, according to a Missouri GOP congressman.

But if Missouri Republicans do target Missouri's Kansas City-based 5th District at the behest of Trump, they'd not only be abandoning their own impassioned arguments from just a couple of years ago – but possibly plunging the state into judicial limbo.

At the beginning of every decade, states redraw congressional districts based on population data released from the U.S. Census Bureau. But states do sometimes redraw maps either at the behest of courts – or because the political party in charge wants to give advantages ahead of congressional elections.

With the GOP's grip on Congress looking dicey ahead of the 2026 midterm elections, Trump is publicly urging Texas to overhaul its congressional map so that Republicans can win an additional five seats. California Gov. Gavin Newsom said recently that if Texas goes through with that plan, he'll set in motion a bid to make his state's map even more Democratic.

Congressman Eric Burlison told St. Louis Public Radio on Thursday that he heard directly from the White House that the president wants the GOP-controlled legislature to revamp its map to make it difficult, if not impossible, for Democratic Congressman Emanuel Cleaver of Kansas City to win re-election.

"I literally just got off the phone with the White House – and they do want that," said Burlison, R-Greene County. "And this is the first that I've heard it directly from them, because before that I heard it through rumors – through other people."

Your donation is more critical now than it has ever been. Stand with public media and donate today.

The White House didn't return a message from St. Louis Public Radio inquiring about Trump's desire to get a more Republican-leaning map in Missouri. But a number of high-level Republican operatives have confirmed reports from Punchbowl News and Puck that the White House is angling for Missouri to redraw its map.

A spokeswoman for Gov. Mike Kehoe didn't return several messages for comment about whether the GOP governor would call a redistricting special session, likely to occur in the fall. House Speaker Jon Patterson and Senate President Pro Tem Cindy O'Laughlin both told St. Louis Public Radio they've received no communication from anyone about wanting a redistricting special session.

A smattering of people walk through the Missouri Capitol rotunda on Thursday morning, the day after the Senate adjourned in Jefferson City.
Brian Munoz / St. Louis Public Radio
/
St. Louis Public Radio
A smattering of people walk through the Missouri Capitol rotunda the morning after the state senate abruptly adjourned on Thursday, May 15, 2025, in Jefferson City.

Reigniting a fight 

The surprise reemergence of Missouri redistricting comes as U.S. House Republicans hold a tenuous majority. Some observers, including Senate Minority Leader Doug Beck, said the fact that national Republicans want to squeeze an extra seat out of Missouri shows how pessimistic they are about retaining the majority during the 2026 midterm elections.

The bloodbath that happened in '18, that's what they're worried about," said Beck, D-St. Louis County. "It's like that, but on steroids. They're attacking people, and they're taking away health care from people. And it's not going to work. It's going to work against them."

Burlison, though, said the move to target Cleaver isn't a sign of Republican panic.

"It's such a thin majority. It's so thin that every seat is going to count," Burlison said. "And that was the argument that was made when we were going through redistricting."

What Burlison was referring to was how Republicans quarreled publicly in 2022 about whether to go after Cleaver – or to have six relatively safe Republican seats and two safe Democratic seats. The legislature ultimately went with the so-called '6 to 2' map, primarily because of fears that splitting Kansas City up could make the 4th and 6th District more competitive.

"What it could do is in a competitive election year, like maybe the midterm elections which usually don't go well for the president's party, is make those districts competitive where now the Republican Party has to invest time and resources into those districts, " said University of Missouri-St. Louis political science professor Anita Manion. "And so, it could open up the potential for Democrats to pick up some seats, although I won't say that that's likely."

Many prominent Republicans, including some who are currently in GOP leadership in the General Assembly, passionately argued against a 7 to 1 map. They contended it made sense to have Kansas City in a geographically compact area, as opposed to having it diced up into largely rural-dominated districts.

But Burlison, who generally stayed out of the redistricting fights in 2022 but supported a 7 to 1 map, said the rejection of a 7 to 1 map had more to do with disdain for some that plan's proponents – then-Sens. Bill Eigel and Bob Onder. He contends the dynamics will change now that Trump is making the ask.

"They were risk adverse. And then, I also think just the fact that you had the number one advocates for 7 to 1 were people that they couldn't stand like Bill Eigel," Burlison said. "The Missouri Senate had Bill Eigel derangement syndrome in a lot of ways."

Beck said it speaks volumes that Republicans in Missouri are willing to pursue mid-decade redistricting at the behest of Trump – especially since he's facing heat over the release of the Jeffrey Epstein files. 

"It's a blatant power grab by an administration that's desperate to deflect from their cover up on the Epstein files," Beck said.

The Missouri State Capitol on Thursday, May 11, 2023, in Jefferson City.
Brian Munoz / St. Louis Public Radio
/
St. Louis Public Radio
The Missouri State Capitol on Thursday, May 11, 2023, in Jefferson City.

Could it be done?

Contrary to some assumptions, Republicans do have the ability to transform Cleaver's district into a solid Republican seat. Unlike the 1st Congressional District, it's not protected under the Voting Rights Act because it doesn't have a majority minority population.

And since the redraw would likely be done in a special session this year, Democrats would have less leverage to stop it from going to Kehoe's desk. That's because Democratic filibusters are more effective during regular sessions, when the party can hold up other major items to block legislation from passing.

But it's an open question whether any map would stand up to judicial scrutiny.

Jim Layton is a former Missouri solicitor general who defended the state's congressional maps in court back in the 2010s. He said it would be a near certainty that someone would sue if the legislature tried to change the map.

"The Constitution requires that it be done after the decennial census, and it doesn't address whether it can be done at another time," Layton said. "I would expect that someone would challenge the map, saying that under our Constitution, there's only one chance after each census to create a new map."

Layton also said a new map would face another problem: Because the most recent Census data comes from 2020, it's highly possible that someone could say the map doesn't conform to constitutional guidelines saying districts need to be "nearly equal in population as may be."

"We don't have real census numbers other than from the decennial census every 10 years. Anything else is an estimate," Layton said. "But we know from those estimates that things have changed. That the numbers that we had from 2020 are not the numbers that we would have today. So there certainly could be an opportunity for someone to challenge any new districts by saying that, as of today, those districts are not equal."

But Washington University law professor Travis Crum said that similar arguments against a Texas map that was redrawn in the 2000s failed in court. He also said that if states weren't allowed to change their maps in the middle of the decade, it could create logistical problems.

"It's pretty common for state legislative maps and congressional maps to be invalidated on some type of grounds a few years into the redistricting cycle, – they violate section two of the Voting Rights Act or something like that," Crum said. "And in those circumstances, you often have general assemblies redrawing state maps in years ending in three or four. And if the claim is that you can't rely on census data that's now, at that point, three or four years old .. you'd be in a bind, right?"

The bigger issue for Republicans in the General Assembly could be less a legal problem and more a practical one.

If Republicans do successfully target Cleaver, it could incentivize Democrats, especially in the Senate, to block as many GOP-led initiatives as possible. Democrats are already planning for some sort of retribution after Republicans forced votes on measures taking aim at voter-approved abortion rights and paid leave initiatives. 

Beck said he already has tenuous relationships with some GOP senators, including those in leadership.

"I hope that changes at some point, but there's going to have to be some changes made to make that happen," Beck said.


Copyright 2025 St. Louis Public Radio

Since entering the world of professional journalism in 2006, Jason Rosenbaum dove head first into the world of politics, policy and even rock and roll music. A graduate of the University of Missouri School of Journalism, Rosenbaum spent more than four years in the Missouri State Capitol writing for the Columbia Daily Tribune, Missouri Lawyers Media and the St. Louis Beacon. Since moving to St. Louis in 2010, Rosenbaum's work appeared in Missouri Lawyers Media, the St. Louis Business Journal and the Riverfront Times' music section. He also served on staff at the St. Louis Beacon as a politics reporter. Rosenbaum lives in Richmond Heights with with his wife Lauren and their two sons.
Congress just eliminated federal funding for KCUR, but public radio is for the people.

Your support has always made KCUR's work possible — from reporting that keeps officials accountable, to storytelling to connects our community. Help ensure the future of local journalism.