© 2025 Kansas City Public Radio
NPR in Kansas City
Play Live Radio
Next Up:
0:00
0:00
0:00 0:00
Available On Air Stations

Pro Football Hall of Fame denies entry to controversial Chiefs player Jim Tyrer

Jim Tyrer stands with his wife, Martha Tyrer, on the night he was inducted into the Chiefs Hall of Fame. For the first time in 45 years he was a finalist for the Pro Football Hall of Fame.
Kevin Patrick Allen
Jim Tyrer stands with his wife, Martha Tyrer, on the night he was inducted into the Chiefs Hall of Honor in 1977. Tyrer killed his wife and himself in 1980.

Although his on-field accomplishments made him unquestionably qualified for induction, Jim Tyrer was a controversial nomination from the start — because he killed his wife and himself in 1980. Advocates say it's a missed opportunity to further discussions around CTE.

Family, friends and advocates of Jim Tyrer, a senior class nominee for the 2025 Pro Football Hall of Fame, were frustrated to see him fail to receive enough votes for induction.

Tyrer was a finalist for the first time in 45 years.

"Obviously, we were all disappointed that the Hall of Fame voters didn't see it the way the Blue Ribbon Senior Committee saw it in terms of my dad's candidacy," son Brad Tyrer told KCUR's Up To Date.

Tyrer's on-field credentials exceed that of other nominees, but his nomination was controversial because of his off-field actions.

Experts presume the retired, offensive-tackle was suffering from chronic traumatic encephalopathy (CTE) when he killed his wife and then himself in 1980, according to "Beneath the Shadow," documentarian Kevin Patrick Allen.

Because the Pro Hall of Fame bylaws explicitly state only the athlete's on-field performance should be considered during candidacy, advocates say Tyrer should have been inducted — and hoped his case should be used to advance the conversation around CTE.

"I had hoped that there would be robust discussion that went beyond the bylaw, because I think it is important to speak to the very issues we've been talking about, about bringing CTE more into the open, and acknowledging that that is the monster in the room," said Kansas City Star sports columnist Vahe Gregorian, who is on the voting board of the HOF.

Stay Connected
When I host Up To Date each morning at 9, my aim is to engage the community in conversations about the Kansas City area’s challenges, hopes and opportunities. I try to ask the questions that listeners want answered about the day’s most pressing issues and provide a place for residents to engage directly with newsmakers. Reach me at steve@kcur.org or on Twitter @stevekraske.
When you listen to Up To Date, I want you to understand decisions being made in the city, feel inspired by community members, and empathize with people who've had different experiences. As an Up To Date producer, I connect you to the news through conversations with community members and elected officials. Contact me at elizabeth@kcur.org or on Twitter at @er_bentley_ruiz.
No matter what happens in Washington D.C., Kansas City needs KCUR. And KCUR needs you.

Our ability to report local news — accurate, independent and paywall-free — depends on you. Donate now to support fact-based news.